Skip to main content

NHECHS - HCCS Library Instruction: Databases vs. Search Engines

This guide compiles instructional materials selected by HCC Librarian Jenn B. Stidham for library instructions sessions designed for North Houston Early College High School students.

Databases

Database Logos

 

 

Databases vs. Search Engines: What's the Difference?

Databases (Library databases are available 24/7 from the HCC Library web page: A-Z Databases)

What: A database is an organized collection of electronic, digitized information that can be searched in a variety of ways. Databases typically include information from magazines, journals, newspapers, and electronic books. Since most of the information found in a database has previously appeared in print form, it has gone through the editorial process. As a result, there is the expectation that the information included in a database is credible and reliable.

How: Databases are provided to the library by vendors as part of a subscription service - no different than the library subscribing to an individual magazine, journal or newspaper. These are not free services available to anyone on the web. However, they are available for free to registered HCC students (your tuition dollars pay for access). Databases are selected by the library to support courses and programs offered at HCC.

Why Use a Database:

• Information is organized: Articles and other types of information are collected, organized and made available by the database provider. You may search for information by keyword, subject heading, author, title, and more. Results can be very relevant.

• Reliability: Most of the information included in a database has gone through the editorial process - it has been checked for accuracy and reliability.

• Ease of access: Databases provided by the library are available 24/7. You have access to thousands of high quality, full text magazines, journals, newspapers, and more.

Bottom line: If you are looking for credible, scholarly information that is carefully organized and easily accessible, use an appropriate database. 

Types of Databases: Essentially, there are two basic types of databases made available by the library:

Multi-Subject/General Databases: These are large databases that provide full text access to thousands of magazine, journal, and newspaper articles on virtually all subjects.

• Examples of Multi-Subject Databases

o Academic Search Premier

o Academic OneFile

o ProQuest Research Library

Subject Databases: Subject databases typically collect and organize information based on specific subjects or disciplines such as business, health, geography, history, literature, etc.

• Examples of Subject Databases

o Business Source Complete

o Health Source: Consumer Edition

o Global Road Warrior

o Literary Reference Center

o Psychology and Behavioral Sciences Collection  

Specialized Databases vs. WWW Search Engines

Databbases vs Google

Search Engines

Search Engine LogosSearch Engines

What: Information on the web is not collected and organized in any meaningful way - it is a vast reservoir of articles, ads, propaganda, opinions of every variety, full text books, government documents, and so much more. A search engine will allow you to search for information found on the web using simple keywords, but they lack the advanced search capabilities provide by most databases. Also, most information found on the web has not gone through the editorial process - anyone can "publish" whatever they like on the web. Consequently, there is no guarantee that information found on the web is credible or reliable.

How: Search engines use software called "spiders" and "crawlers" to routinely scour the web to identify and index web pages. The software used by each search engine works a bit differently. The same search conducted with different search engines will yield different results. You may want to try your search in more than one search engine and compare results. Also keep in mind that information on the web is very dynamic - information is constantly added, deleted, moved, and changed. There is no guarantee that what you find today will be there tomorrow. 

Why Use a Search Engine:

• You are looking for information about an organization (American Medical Association), a city/county/state/ agency (Harris County Tax Assessor's Office), or other specialized information.

• You are looking for very specific or obscure information (dates, statistics, etc.).

• You are seeking information for personal uses: how much is my 1995 Honda Accord worth?

Caution: Critically evaluate any information you use for academic assignments - especially information found on the web. 

Examples of Search Engines:

Google

Yahoo Search

Bing

Ask

Activity - Compare Databases and Search Engines

ACTIVITY: Compare Them!

Instructions:

1. Compare a search for items containing both phrases “United States” and “female serial killers” in the HCC Library system's subscription article database Academic Search Complete and in the web search engine Bing. (Make sure you include the quotation makes so they will be searched as phrases.) Notice how searching too narrowly (searching for phrases) affects results in the specialized database. How could you revise the specialized database search to get more results?

2. We want to find the article in Consumer Reports that will help us settle an argument that you are having with a friend - What are the best frozen waffles? Go to the Consumer Reports website and see what information is available there. Can we answer the question here? What happens when we try to access the article that rates the various frozen waffle brands? What is your next step? HINT - try the HCC Library Journal Finder.

 

Credit

Much of the material on this page was used with kind written permission from the College of Southern Nevada Libraries. The original source may be located at - https://www.csn.edu/sites/default/files/legacy/PDFFiles/Library/dbasesearch3.pdf

©2020 Houston Community College Libraries